Public records slow to arrive during pandemic


By DAVID A. LIEB - Associated Press



ADVANCE FOR RELEASE MARCH 14, 2021, AND THEREAFTER - FILE - In this June 30, 2020, photo, a man passes a clothing shop with open signs in the window in Calexico, Calif. A year after the first coronavirus shutdowns, many U.S. states and cities are still struggling with a silent side effect: Public records have become harder to get. As states prepared to reopen their economies following coronavirus shutdowns last spring, The Associated Press asked governors across the U.S. for records that could shed light on how businesses and health officials influenced their decisions. (AP Photo/Gregory Bull, File)

ADVANCE FOR RELEASE MARCH 14, 2021, AND THEREAFTER - FILE - In this June 30, 2020, photo, a man passes a clothing shop with open signs in the window in Calexico, Calif. A year after the first coronavirus shutdowns, many U.S. states and cities are still struggling with a silent side effect: Public records have become harder to get. As states prepared to reopen their economies following coronavirus shutdowns last spring, The Associated Press asked governors across the U.S. for records that could shed light on how businesses and health officials influenced their decisions. (AP Photo/Gregory Bull, File)


ADVANCE FOR RELEASE MARCH 14, 2021, AND THEREAFTER - FILE - This Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2020 file photo shows Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine looking on during a news conference at Toledo Express Airport in Swanton, Ohio. A year after the first coronavirus shutdowns, many U.S. states and cities are still struggling with a silent side effect: Public records have become harder to get. After months of repeated AP inquiries, DeWine's office on March 3, 2021, released just two documents from last spring — one from a hospital association proposing criteria for resuming elective procedures. (J.D. Pooley/Sentinel-Tribune via AP, File)

ADVANCE FOR RELEASE MARCH 14, 2021, AND THEREAFTER - FILE - This Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2020 file photo shows Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine looking on during a news conference at Toledo Express Airport in Swanton, Ohio. A year after the first coronavirus shutdowns, many U.S. states and cities are still struggling with a silent side effect: Public records have become harder to get. After months of repeated AP inquiries, DeWine's office on March 3, 2021, released just two documents from last spring — one from a hospital association proposing criteria for resuming elective procedures. (J.D. Pooley/Sentinel-Tribune via AP, File)


ADVANCE FOR RELEASE MARCH 14, 2021, AND THEREAFTER - FILE - In this Oct. 15, 2020, file photo, Hawaii Gov. David Ige speaks at a news conference at the Daniel K. Inouye International Airport in Honolulu. A year after the first coronavirus shutdowns, many U.S. states and cities are still struggling with a silent side effect: Public records have become harder to get. Ige, a Democrat, took the most sweeping action when he suspended the state’s entire open-records law in March 2020. Ige eased the suspension under pressure from open-government advocates. (AP Photo/Marco Garcia, File)


As states prepared to reopen their economies following coronavirus shutdowns last spring, The Associated Press asked governors across the U.S. for records that could shed light on how businesses and health officials influenced their decisions.

Nine months later, after several more COVID-19 surges and shutdowns, the AP still has not received records from about 20 states. Some outright denied the requests or sought payments the AP declined to make. Others have not responded, or said they still need more time.

Public records have become harder to get since the world was upended by the pandemic a year ago. Governors, legislatures and local officials have suspended or ignored laws setting deadlines to respond to records requests. They cited obstacles for staffers who are working at home or are overwhelmed with crisis management.

The result is that information that once took a few days or weeks to obtain now often takes months — depriving the public of timely facts about decisions their leaders are making.

“The pandemic rages on, but investigative journalism doesn’t halt. The public’s right to know doesn’t cease to exist,” said Gunita Singh, a legal fellow at the Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press, which has tracked nationwide delays in responding to public records requests.

“Having these unnecessary measures in place that hinder open government sets a terrible precedent,” Singh said.

U.S. states and local governments are far from alone in their deferrals and delays. Dozens of countries suspended or altered their right-to-information policies last year while citing the pandemic, according to a joint tracking effort by the Centre for Law and Democracy and Access Info Europe.

Open-government advocates have started to worry about potential long-lasting effects.

The pandemic could “give cover for emergency measures to come into force that could then over time become permanent,” said Joe Powell, deputy CEO of the Open Government Partnership, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit that works with governments in 78 countries, including the U.S., to promote transparency and public participation.

Even before the pandemic, some government agencies routinely blew past their own deadlines for responding to public records requests. But the number of such cases has grown over the past year, according to AP interviews with government watchdog groups.

New data indicates there has been both a higher demand for government information during the pandemic and longer waits to obtain it.

State, county and city governments experienced a sixfold increase in their time spent on public records requests last year, rising from an average of 346 hours in the first quarter to 2,121 hours by the last quarter, according to an analysis by GovQA, a company that provides cloud-based software to manage public records requests.

That surge was driven by both the volume and complexity of requests. After shutdowns led to a dip in records requests accepted by government agencies from April to June, the number of such requests shot up by 23% over the rest of the year, according to the GovQA data.

Processing delays were exacerbated by remote work, outdated public-records laws, underfunded budgets and increased oversight from top administrators wanting to review potentially sensitive data before it was released, said GovQA spokesperson Jen Snyder.

The AP last May sought copies of communications about the coronavirus between governors’ offices, state health directors and groups representing businesses, health care providers and local governments. By August, the AP had received records from about one-third of the states, revealing that some governors had allowed businesses to help write the reopening rules affecting their own industries.

The AP still has requests pending in Hawaii, Idaho, Iowa, Kansas, Maine, New York and Texas. Illinois this past week finally provided 74 pages of documents, heavily redacted.

After months of repeated AP inquiries, Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine’s office on March 3 released just two documents from last spring — one from a hospital association proposing criteria for resuming elective procedures, the other from a mayor’s group about guidelines for opening swimming pools and camps. A spokesperson for the Republican governor apologized for the delay, citing “human error” for a breakdown of staff communication.

ADVANCE FOR RELEASE MARCH 14, 2021, AND THEREAFTER - FILE - In this June 30, 2020, photo, a man passes a clothing shop with open signs in the window in Calexico, Calif. A year after the first coronavirus shutdowns, many U.S. states and cities are still struggling with a silent side effect: Public records have become harder to get. As states prepared to reopen their economies following coronavirus shutdowns last spring, The Associated Press asked governors across the U.S. for records that could shed light on how businesses and health officials influenced their decisions. (AP Photo/Gregory Bull, File)
https://www.limaohio.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/54/2021/03/web1_126362359-1c2572490a42494cb4d5c867210638ec.jpgADVANCE FOR RELEASE MARCH 14, 2021, AND THEREAFTER - FILE - In this June 30, 2020, photo, a man passes a clothing shop with open signs in the window in Calexico, Calif. A year after the first coronavirus shutdowns, many U.S. states and cities are still struggling with a silent side effect: Public records have become harder to get. As states prepared to reopen their economies following coronavirus shutdowns last spring, The Associated Press asked governors across the U.S. for records that could shed light on how businesses and health officials influenced their decisions. (AP Photo/Gregory Bull, File)
ADVANCE FOR RELEASE MARCH 14, 2021, AND THEREAFTER - FILE - This Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2020 file photo shows Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine looking on during a news conference at Toledo Express Airport in Swanton, Ohio. A year after the first coronavirus shutdowns, many U.S. states and cities are still struggling with a silent side effect: Public records have become harder to get. After months of repeated AP inquiries, DeWine's office on March 3, 2021, released just two documents from last spring — one from a hospital association proposing criteria for resuming elective procedures. (J.D. Pooley/Sentinel-Tribune via AP, File)
https://www.limaohio.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/54/2021/03/web1_126362359-408da1b3e6594907bbf6d3ae6f6098af.jpgADVANCE FOR RELEASE MARCH 14, 2021, AND THEREAFTER - FILE - This Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2020 file photo shows Ohio Gov. Mike DeWine looking on during a news conference at Toledo Express Airport in Swanton, Ohio. A year after the first coronavirus shutdowns, many U.S. states and cities are still struggling with a silent side effect: Public records have become harder to get. After months of repeated AP inquiries, DeWine's office on March 3, 2021, released just two documents from last spring — one from a hospital association proposing criteria for resuming elective procedures. (J.D. Pooley/Sentinel-Tribune via AP, File)
ADVANCE FOR RELEASE MARCH 14, 2021, AND THEREAFTER - FILE - In this Oct. 15, 2020, file photo, Hawaii Gov. David Ige speaks at a news conference at the Daniel K. Inouye International Airport in Honolulu. A year after the first coronavirus shutdowns, many U.S. states and cities are still struggling with a silent side effect: Public records have become harder to get. Ige, a Democrat, took the most sweeping action when he suspended the state’s entire open-records law in March 2020. Ige eased the suspension under pressure from open-government advocates. (AP Photo/Marco Garcia, File)
https://www.limaohio.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/54/2021/03/web1_126362359-99a2f2f994c64e16b6709ee062a5a24e.jpgADVANCE FOR RELEASE MARCH 14, 2021, AND THEREAFTER - FILE - In this Oct. 15, 2020, file photo, Hawaii Gov. David Ige speaks at a news conference at the Daniel K. Inouye International Airport in Honolulu. A year after the first coronavirus shutdowns, many U.S. states and cities are still struggling with a silent side effect: Public records have become harder to get. Ige, a Democrat, took the most sweeping action when he suspended the state’s entire open-records law in March 2020. Ige eased the suspension under pressure from open-government advocates. (AP Photo/Marco Garcia, File)

By DAVID A. LIEB

Associated Press

Post navigation