Dear Car Talk:
I have a turbo six-cylinder car that calls for 93 octane gasoline. If I were to hock my stepson and kick my dog until she ran away, I could finally afford to fill the gas tank with high octane fuel.
If, on the other hand, I could safely use regular gasoline instead without causing harm to my engine or turbo, I would be able to bring back my dog with the savings.
Can I do that without negative consequences? — Sy
It depends, Sy.
This is one of those things people often overlook when buying a new car. You drive it, you see how it rides, how it accelerates, how it looks, how the seats conform to each butt cheek. But most people never open the fuel door or check the owner’s manual to see what kind of fuel it takes.
If you buy a car that requires 93 octane gasoline, you’re going to spend 25-40 cents more per gallon at every fill-up for the life of your car.
One of reasons some engines can produce a lot of power for their size is that they compress the fuel air mixture at much higher pressure. They’re called high-compression engines.
But in order to prevent pinging (or preignition) in high compression engines, they need a fuel with a higher ignition point. That’s what higher octane fuel has.
So why do I say the answer to your question “depends,” Sy? Because it depends on whether your owner’s manual says “Requires 93 octane” or “93 octane recommended.”
If your manufacturer recommends 93 octane, that means the car is designed to perform optimally on 93 octane fuel. It may have an iota more power and possibly a hair better gas mileage when you fill it with 93. But it also means the car has a knock sensor that will adjust the spark timing when you use lower octane fuel to prevent the engine from pinging, and keep the engine from getting damaged due to overheating.
On the other hand, cars that “require” high octane fuel also have knock sensors, but for whatever reason, the manufacturer makes no guarantee that you won’t damage your engine if you cheap out and run it on regular fuel.
So, if it says “requires 93 octane,” then you’re out of luck, Sy. As is your dog, who was probably looking forward to shedding all over the backseat of that BMW.
Next time you go car shopping, put that on your list of things to check. And then you’ll know in advance whether you have to choose between the Five Series and Fido.
Got a question about cars? Write to Car Talk write to Ray in care of King Features, 628 Virginia Drive, Orlando, FL 32803, or email by visiting the Car Talk website at www.cartalk.com.