1. Fat Jack’s
1806 N. West St., Lima; 801 Findlay Road, Lima; 2340 Spencerville Road, Lima
2. Beer Barrel
1840 S. Dixie Highway, Lima; 2625 W. Market St., Lima; 1200 Indiana Ave., St. Marys
3. The Pizzeria
112 N. High St., Columbus Grove; 103 E. Main St., Kalida; 102 E. Main St., Leipsic; 1085 N. Perry St., Ottawa; 206 E. Main St., Pandora
Honorable Mentions: T.J.’s Pizza, Elida; Chuffer’s Drive-Thru, Spencerville; Westgate Entertainment Center, Lima

Emma Overholtz prepares a pizza at Fat Jack’s on North Street in Lima.