1. Kewpee
111 N. Elizabeth St., Lima; 2111 Allentown Road, Lima; 1350 Bellefontaine Road, Lima
2. Five Guys Burgers and Fries
3292 Elida Road, Lima
3. 12 East
2310 Harding Highway, Lima
Honorable Mentions: Canalside Burgers and Brews, Ottoville; Tony’s, Ottawa; Tilton Hilton, Lakeview

Freshly prepared hamburgers are part of Kewpee’s recipe for success, especially at the original location in downtown Lima.